A recent study published in Translational Psychiatry reveals that older adults who feel criticized by close family or friends are more likely to develop symptoms of depression over time. The research, spanning 17 years and involving adults aged 50 and above in England, shows that even mild criticism can negatively impact mental health—especially for women.
The study explored how criticism from spouses, children, other family members, or friends influences depression risk in later life. Results indicate that both frequent and occasional criticism increase the chances of developing depression, with women showing greater sensitivity to these effects than men.
Depression is a common and serious mental health issue among older adults. It often worsens physical health, contributing to heart disease, stroke, and difficulties managing other illnesses. Depression can also lead to social isolation, cognitive decline, and higher mortality. Although treatments exist, they don’t always work, making it crucial to identify preventable risk factors.
One such factor is the quality of social relationships. Older adults often experience changes in family roles and greater dependence on loved ones, which can heighten sensitivity to criticism. Negative feedback from close connections can erode self-esteem and harm mental well-being. Past studies suggested links between criticism and depression but could not confirm if criticism causes depression or vice versa.
To clarify this, researchers analyzed nearly two decades of data from the English Longitudinal Study of Ageing, which follows thousands of people aged 50 and older through interviews every two years. The study grouped participants by the types of close relationships they had: spouses/partners, children, other family, and friends.
Depression was measured using a brief, validated questionnaire focused on symptoms like sadness, sleep problems, and loss of interest. Only participants without depression at the start were included.
Participants reported how much criticism they perceived from each relationship type, answering “not at all,” “a little,” “some,” or “a lot.” Between 23% and 25% of participants developed depressive symptoms during the study period. Those reporting higher criticism had a greater risk of depression, with even small amounts of criticism from children, family, or friends increasing risk. For spouses, the risk was higher only with “some” or “a lot” of criticism.
Women were more vulnerable: even mild criticism from close ones raised their depression risk, while men showed increased risk mainly after high criticism levels. This may reflect women’s greater sensitivity to emotional dynamics and a tendency to internalize negative experiences.
The researchers confirmed these findings by excluding participants who became depressed early in the study and by examining the combined impact of criticism from multiple sources. The more relationships where criticism was perceived, the higher the depression risk.
However, the study has limitations. It relies on self-reported criticism, which reflects personal perception rather than objective behavior. People prone to negative thinking might report more criticism and depression. Also, the results mainly represent older adults in the UK and might differ elsewhere. The study’s observational nature means it can’t prove cause and effect conclusively.
Still, this research underscores a vital message: older adults may suffer in silence when criticized by loved ones. Feeling criticized repeatedly can have lasting mental health consequences. Maintaining positive, supportive relationships is as important as having connections at all. Loved ones can protect older adults’ mental health by showing kindness and understanding, avoiding harsh judgments, and communicating respectfully.
This study, “Perceived criticism and depressive symptoms among adults aged 50 years and older: a 17-year population-based cohort study,” was led by Yanzhi Li and colleagues.
Related topics:
