Michigan’s individual health insurance market is facing its most significant upheaval since the launch of the Affordable Care Act (ACA). Four insurance providers — HAP CareSource, Molina, Physicians Health Plan (University of Michigan Health Plan), and Meridian — are withdrawing from the marketplace in 2026. Their departure will impact over 200,000 residents who currently rely on these insurers for coverage.
The open enrollment period for 2026 health plans runs from November 1 to January 15, but this year’s process may prove particularly difficult for Michiganders seeking affordable coverage options. Meridian, while maintaining operations in 30 counties, will end coverage for residents of metro Detroit, including Wayne, Oakland, Macomb, and Monroe counties.
Loss of Federal Subsidies Threatens Affordability
The situation is compounded by the expiration of expanded federal ACA subsidies—introduced during the COVID-19 pandemic under President Joe Biden—which had significantly reduced costs for middle- and upper-middle-income earners. Without congressional approval for an extension, millions of Americans will see their health insurance premiums double or even triple in 2026.
The federal government shutdown, which began on October 1, stems partly from partisan disagreements over renewing these subsidies. While the Senate passed a resolution to reopen the government, the measure omitted an extension for the extra financial aid.
According to the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget, ACA subsidies — both original and expanded — cost the federal government an estimated $138 billion in 2025. If the expansion lapses, individuals earning more than four times the federal poverty level ($62,600 for one person or $128,600 for a family of four) will lose access to premium support entirely.
Premiums Climb as Risk Pools Shrink
The Michigan Department of Insurance and Financial Services (DIFS) recently approved an average 20% premium increase for 2026, marking the second-largest hike since the ACA marketplace’s debut in 2014. Currently, more than 530,000 Michiganders are enrolled in marketplace plans — a steep rise from 300,000 in 2020.
Experts attribute the increase partly to insurers’ expectations that fewer healthy individuals will remain in the marketplace after subsidies end. This shift leaves a higher proportion of sicker individuals in the insurance pool, driving costs higher across the board.
While the original ACA subsidies remain for those earning between 100% and 400% of the federal poverty line, middle-income policyholders above that threshold face “sticker shock.” Their premiums could rise far beyond 20%, in some cases doubling or tripling.
Personal Stories of Impact
For many residents, the changes are personal and devastating.
Cortney Strother, a 61-year-old small business owner from Berkley, currently pays $289 a month for his ACA “silver” plan. A $627 monthly subsidy offsets his full premium cost of $916. When he received notice that his insurer, HAP CareSource, will exit the market, Strother described the news as “a kick to the midsection.”
“I’ve been very happy with the Affordable Care Act options,” Strother said. “But if my bills reach $1,000 a month, I don’t know what I’ll do.”
U.S. Senator Elissa Slotkin (D-Michigan) and Senator Gary Peters both voted against reopening the government without extending the ACA subsidies. “To earn my vote,” Slotkin said, “Republicans would have to do something to bring down the cost of health care for working and middle-class Michiganders.”
Similarly, Annika Vanderwerf, 25, from Houghton in Michigan’s Upper Peninsula, said she currently pays under $10 per month thanks to expanded subsidies. The lowest-priced plan she found for 2026 is $380 per month. “It’s a little anxiety-inducing,” she admitted, adding that she may be forced to switch to her employer’s plan.
Insurers Explain Their Withdrawals
Among the four exiting insurers, only HAP CareSource provided a detailed explanation. The company rejoined Michigan’s ACA marketplace in 2025 after a seven-year absence, anticipating modest enrollment. Instead, nearly 20,000 customers signed up.
According to HAP President Margaret Anderson, the company initially planned to continue offering coverage in 2026 with a 26% premium increase. However, after other insurers withdrew, federal regulators sought to automatically reassign up to 100,000 displaced enrollees to HAP.
“When we did the modeling, the math was very grim,” Anderson said. “We would have lost significant money and needed to add over $100 million to our reserves. Given that, we decided exiting the marketplace was in the best interest of our remaining members.”
Conclusion
Despite the departures, seven insurers will continue to offer ACA plans in Michigan next year. However, with premiums climbing, subsidies expiring, and competition shrinking, many residents face limited and costly choices.
Health policy analysts warn that unless federal support is restored, private health insurance for Michigan’s individual market could become prohibitively expensive for tens of thousands — marking a pivotal moment for the future of affordable care in the state.
Related topics
