When Dr. Will Bynum was a second-year family medicine resident, an emergency delivery left him hiding in an empty hospital room, overwhelmed by shame. Though he had successfully used vacuum extraction to save the baby’s life, the mother experienced severe vaginal tearing requiring surgical repair.
This pivotal moment sparked Bynum’s journey to understand how shame permeates medical culture. Now an associate professor at Duke University School of Medicine, Bynum has become a leading voice in addressing what he calls the “silent epidemic” of shame in healthcare.
The Ripple Effects of Medical Shame
Shame’s impact extends far beyond individual discomfort. Research shows that unaddressed shame among clinicians can negatively affect patient care and outcomes. When physicians feel shamed, they may unconsciously transmit these feelings to patients, potentially leading to defensive reactions, avoidance of care, and even substance abuse.
A 2023 study found that one-third of physicians reported feeling disdain when treating type 2 diabetes patients, with 44% perceiving these patients as unmotivated and 39% as lazy. These attitudes can create barriers to effective treatment and damage therapeutic relationships.
Political Climate Amplifying Shame Narratives
The current political environment has exacerbated shame-based approaches to healthcare. Former Trump administration health officials, including HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., have publicly blamed patients for conditions like autism, diabetes, and ADHD, suggesting lifestyle choices cause these chronic issues.
FDA Commissioner Marty Makary famously claimed diabetes could be better treated through cooking classes than insulin injections. Such rhetoric reinforces shame-based approaches that research shows can drive patients away from essential care.
Patient Perspectives: The Human Cost
Christa Reed, a 45-year-old wedding photographer from Minneapolis, avoided routine medical care for twenty years after enduring weight-shaming during pregnancy. “They told me my morning sickness was because I was a plus-size, overweight woman,” she recalled.
Only when severe jaw pain led to the discovery of dangerously high blood pressure did she re-engage with healthcare. Reed’s experience illustrates how shaming drives patients from the system, with potentially life-threatening consequences.
Innovative Approaches to Shame Resilience
Dr. Bynum and colleagues are developing “shame competence” training to help medical professionals recognize and address shame. This approach acknowledges that while shame cannot be eliminated, clinicians can develop skills to prevent its transmission to patients and colleagues. The training focuses on:
- Recognizing shame responses in oneself and others
- Reframing mistakes as learning opportunities rather than personal failures
- Developing resilience through supportive peer networks
- Creating cultures where vulnerability can be safely expressed
- Institutional Implementation and Early Results
Through The Shame Lab, a research partnership between Duke University and England’s University of Exeter, Bynum’s team has begun rolling out shame competence training. The program started with 20 OB-GYNs and has expanded to reach approximately 300 individuals in Duke’s Department of Family Medicine and Community Health.
Early participants like Dr. Canice Dancel report that the training helps create a “chain reaction of kindness” that improves both team dynamics and patient interactions.
The Path Forward
The movement represents a paradigm shift in medical education, which has traditionally emphasized perfectionism and stoicism. As Dr. Savannah Woodward, a California psychiatrist studying shame spirals, notes: “If your doctor is burned out or feels they don’t deserve to be your doctor, patients can feel that.”
By addressing shame directly, the healthcare community hopes to break cycles that harm both providers and patients, ultimately creating more compassionate and effective care environments.
Related topics:
