A Texas federal judge has ruled that medical debt can legally remain on Americans’ credit reports, striking down a recent federal effort aimed at easing the financial pressure on millions of households struggling with healthcare expenses.
Judge Sean Jordan, of the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas, issued the decision on Friday, stating that the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) had exceeded its authority with a rule it introduced earlier this year.
That rule, set during the final months of the Biden administration, sought to prevent medical debt from impacting a person’s credit rating—a change the CFPB argued was essential to creating a fairer financial system.
Why This Matters
Nearly 100 million people in the United States carry some form of medical debt, according to a joint investigation by Kaiser Health News and NPR. That debt can directly affect access to loans, housing, and job opportunities because credit reports are used to assess a person’s financial reliability.
The CFPB, in support of its now-overturned rule, cited research showing that medical debt is not a strong predictor of loan defaults. In 2014, the bureau concluded that unlike other forms of borrowing, medical debt is often unplanned and does not reflect poor financial behavior. CFPB Director Rohit Chopra said at the time, “People who get sick shouldn’t have their financial future upended.”
However, Judge Jordan sided with the Cornerstone Credit Union League, which filed a lawsuit arguing that the CFPB had no legal authority to enforce such a sweeping rule. The judge’s opinion stated that the rule’s core provisions overstepped the agency’s mandate, effectively invalidating the policy.
Supporters and Critics React
The decision quickly drew criticism from consumer advocates who say it harms those already vulnerable due to illness and unexpected medical costs.
“This ruling is a disappointing setback—but it will not stop the growing movement to protect people from the financial harm of medical debt,” said Colin Reusch, policy director at Community Catalyst, a nonprofit focused on affordable healthcare.
On the other side, industry representatives welcomed the ruling. Dan Smith, president and CEO of the Consumer Data Industry Association (CDIA), said keeping medical debt in credit reports is essential to maintaining a “full, fair, and accurate credit reporting system.”
“Unpaid medical debts provide critical information about a borrower’s ability to repay,” Smith noted, calling the ruling a victory for lending integrity.
A Uniquely American Problem
In most developed countries, healthcare costs are largely covered by public systems or heavily regulated insurance plans. In the U.S., however, even insured individuals often face high deductibles, surprise billing, and other out-of-pocket costs that can lead to financial hardship.
People with substantial medical debt face higher risks of bankruptcy, homelessness, and long-term credit damage. And while more than a dozen states have passed laws to minimize the impact of medical debt on credit scores, a federal standard remains elusive.
Looking Ahead
With the rule overturned, Americans with unpaid medical bills will continue to see those debts reported to credit bureaus, potentially influencing their ability to access credit. The CFPB has not yet announced whether it will appeal the decision.
Advocates say the fight is far from over. Public health and consumer rights groups are expected to push for new legislation or modified rules that could reintroduce similar protections under a different legal framework.
Related topics:
Oregon Secures $10.1M From Opioid Makers in Multi-State Settlement
